How to compare schools without getting lost in hype
Start with your non-negotiables: zone access, commute time, type of school and day-to-day feel. Do a daytime walk or drive past your shortlist, and if you’re new to the city, skim our Melbourne infrastructure, hospitals & transport guide so you understand the key train lines, hospital catchments and traffic pinch points.
Inner Melbourne & inner north (CBD edge, Parkville, Carlton, Fitzroy)
Prioritise tram/train access and do a bell-time walk on your likely commute. Inner zones can be tight, and capacity can change, so confirm your exact address on Find My School before you offer on a property.
Inner east (Kew, Hawthorn, Camberwell, Balwyn, Box Hill)
Many families shortlist zoned government schools here, so zone boundaries matter. Compare school fit and week-to-week logistics (before/after-school care, sport, tutoring, and traffic on key corridors).
South-east (Bentleigh, Carnegie, Oakleigh, Clayton, Glen Waverley)
Look for a suburb pocket that keeps both adult and student commutes predictable. If you’re balancing multiple campuses or workplaces, rail spines usually beat cross-town driving in peak hour.
West & growth corridors (Footscray, Sunshine, Point Cook, Tarneit, Werribee)
Factor in train line frequency and school capacity (growth areas can move fast). If you’re building a shortlist across several pockets, pick 2–3 suburbs per direction and tour efficiently over 2–3 weekends.
Popular family suburbs to compare in the west: Point Cook, Tarneit, Werribee and Hoppers Crossing. If you’re focusing on one side of the city, you can also jump to our best schools in Melbourne western suburbs (2025) guide.
Want help mapping budget to the west? Start with a suburb page: Mortgage Broker Point Cook, Mortgage Broker Tarneit, Mortgage Broker Werribee or Mortgage Broker Hoppers Crossing.
Bayside (Elwood, Brighton, Hampton, Sandringham)
Coastal pockets can mean higher prices but smoother week-to-week routines if you can stay close to schools and transport. Double-check zoning and the practical “daily run” (parking, drop-off, and sport training locations).
Numbers like VCE outcomes or NAPLAN context from My School are useful, but they don’t tell you whether your child will feel known, safe and stretched. Use the official data, then read school newsletters and tour notes alongside suburb guides such as our undervalued suburbs in Melbourne 2026 report to see how the broader area is changing.
If you’re buying, layer school research with a realistic borrowing range and deposit plan. Many families compare “buy in-zone now” with “rentvest near work and buy later”. Our rentvesting guide and rentvesting calculator can help you compare those options, and the First Home Buyer Guide plus our VIC grants explainer outline how schemes and stamp duty rules might shape your budget.